Recreation Venue Step Injury Analysis: Plaintiff Verdict

20190806_Poteet.jpg

The owner of a public venue has a responsibility to ensure that their property is safely navigable by all guests. When an owner fails to meet this goal and an injury occurs, biomechanical analysis can help a jury determine whether or not the owner is at fault and even promote improvements in safety.

In May 2006, Kacee Poteet, age 32, was entering Pirate’s Cove Adventure Golf in Branson, MO, with her husband and three children. Carrying her 18-month-old on her left hip, Ms. Poteet paused on the entry landing to wait for her husband, who was pushing a stroller up the wheelchair ramp. As he drew near, Ms. Poteet stepped off the 11-inch landing with her left foot, unaware that there was no intermediate step to the sidewalk below. As a result of the incident, Ms. Poteet sustained severe fractures to the left ankle.

The Poteets retained Brad Bradshaw, MD, JD, LC, Springfield, MO. to represent them in their case. In turn, Dr. Bradshaw asked Hayes + Associates, Inc., to analyze the biomechanics of Ms. Poteet’s injuries.

H+A Associate, Ellen L. Lee, P.E., evaluated the case based on the fundamental laws of physics, the biomechanics of stair descent, and the forces on Ms. Poteet’s ankle. She determined that the forces on Ms. Poteet’s ankle from unexpectedly stepping off the unguarded landing were substantially greater than established injury tolerance limits for her ankle.

Lee also used the International Building Code guidelines for the design of safe steps to demonstrate that the 11-inch drop at Pirate’s Cove far exceeded safe stair dimensions.

H+A CEO Wilson C. “Toby” Hayes, Ph.D., provided videotaped testimony, and the jury found for the Plaintiff, assigning 65% responsibility to the Defendant.

Subsequent to the incident, Pirate’s Cove installed a barrier at the location so that the only option for entry is the secure two-step descent.

Wilson Hayes

Wilson C. "Toby" Hayes, Ph.D. is a nationally recognized authority on the biomechanics of injury, with over 60 years of experience in academic research and forensic consulting. As the former Maurice E. Mueller Professor of Biomechanics at Harvard Medical School and Professor at the Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, his work defined some of the foundational principles of skeletal mechanics, injury causation and fracture risk. As Founder and President of Hayes+Associates, Inc., he applies this broad expertise to provide clear, scientifically-grounded answers to disputed questions on injury causation for legal, public and commercial clients nationwide.

Core Practice Areas: Vehicle Collisions; Premises Safety/Falls; Products Liability; Worker Safety; Sports & Recreation; Criminal Matters.

https://www.hayesassoc.com
Previous
Previous

Rail Tank Car Coupling Analysis: $15.3 Million Jury Verdict

Next
Next

Balcony Fall Modeling Supports a Defense Verdict