McDonald’s brain injuries were suffered when his head hit the concrete.

McDonald’s brain injuries were suffered when his head hit the concrete.

Not Guilty on Both Counts

On October 30, 2010, in Sioux City, Iowa, Bradley Gregg and Joseph McDonald were in a physical altercation outside a bar. During the fight, Gregg punched McDonald twice in the head, causing him to fall backward, hitting his head on the concrete. McDonald sustained skull fractures and serious bleeding in the brain, which ultimately resulted in his death. Gregg was accused of involuntary manslaughter and of assault causing serious injury.

Hayes + Associates was retained by Mr. Michael Williams of the Sioux City, Iowa Adult Public Defender Office to determine if the blows to McDonald’s head were forceful enough to cause his fatal brain injuries or, instead, if McDonald died from his fall and head impact on the concrete sidewalk.

Based on the biomechanical reconstructions of the punching blows to McDonald’s head and the impact to the back of his head from the sidewalk, the H+A analysis showed that while the punch from Gregg likely knocked McDonald unconscious (a finding substantiated by McDonald’s failure to react reflexively), the punch was not violent enough to cause the fatal head injuries McDonald sustained.

At trial, founder and president Wilson C. “Toby” Hayes, Ph.D., testified that, instead, McDonald’s brain injuries were suffered when his head hit the concrete. Subsequently, after deliberating for three and a half hours, the jury found Gregg not guilty on both counts.

Wilson Hayes

Wilson C. "Toby" Hayes, Ph.D. is a nationally recognized authority on the biomechanics of injury, with over 60 years of experience in academic research and forensic consulting. As the former Maurice E. Mueller Professor of Biomechanics at Harvard Medical School and Professor at the Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, his work defined some of the foundational principles of skeletal mechanics, injury causation and fracture risk. As Founder and President of Hayes+Associates, Inc., he applies this broad expertise to provide clear, scientifically-grounded answers to disputed questions on injury causation for legal, public and commercial clients nationwide.

Core Practice Areas: Vehicle Collisions; Premises Safety/Falls; Products Liability; Worker Safety; Sports & Recreation; Criminal Matters.

https://www.hayesassoc.com
Previous
Previous

Falling Pumpkin Injury Analysis Supports Defense Verdict

Next
Next

Low-Speed Rear-End Collision Analysis: Defense Verdict